Is This the Beginning of the End for CC Sabathia?

A day after getting hammered by the Brewers, CC Sabathia has gone on the disabled list for knee inflammation.  These and other recent events have me wondering if this isn’t the turning point signaling the end of CC’s major league career.  I’m not saying that CC is done just yet, but I’m thinking the arc of his career is on the downhill side and picking up speed.

Sabathia’s 4.78 ERA last year was the highest of his career, but he still was a reasonably effective starter who ate up 211 innings for the Yankees and had other numbers which suggested a least the possibility that Sabathia could still have good seasons in the future.  That’s looking an awful lot less likely today.

Aside from the fact that he hasn’t pitched well this season — a 5.28 ERA and 10 home runs allowed, second only in MLB to Jeremy Guthrie — there was a blurb on mlbtraderumors.com a few days ago in which a scout was anonymously quoted saying that Sabathia’s stuff this season is “very fringy” and that he would need “impeccable” control going forward to be effective.

Now the knee problem.  I’ve been saying for years that I thought CC would start having injury problems every year involving his knees, ankles or back starting around age 33, for example, here, since plus-size pitchers have always had these kinds of chronic injury problems by this age.

The current knee injury doesn’t sound too serious, but I expect that from here on in CC will be getting fluid drained off his knees on a regular basis for as long as he continues to be a professional pitcher.  In terms of the red flags raised in my mind by the words “knee injury” in connection with Sabathia, the only words that would cause greater alarm are “shoulder injury” or “lower back disc injury”.

Even if CC comes back and pitches again in only fifteen days, I have a strong suspicion that we’ve seen the last of CC as an elite pitcher at least for periods longer than two or three games at a stretch.

Explore posts in the same categories: Kansas City Royals, New York Yankees

4 Comments on “Is This the Beginning of the End for CC Sabathia?”

  1. kabeiser Says:

    3.76 xFIP last year. 3.11 xFIP this year.

    He hasn’t been as bad as his ERA shows. He shouldn’t be considered a #1/2 but I could see him putting up 3-4 more .500 seasons and 4ish ERA’s.

  2. Burly Says:

    What concerns me the most is the knee problem for the reasons set forth above.

  3. Burly Says:

    The latest words on CC are that he does not have structural damage to his knee (i.e., no torn cartilage, ligaments or tendons), but the Yankees are saying he has a “degenerative condition” in his knee which Dr. James Andrews will treat by giving CC a cortisone shot with stem cells in it. It is still uncertain if future surgery will be needed.

  4. Burly Says:

    The latest, latest word is that CC will be out “at least six weeks” after getting the cortizone-stem cell shot.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: