Rooting for Dellin Betances in Arbitration
The New York Yankees and Dellin Betances are going to arbitration. Betances is asking for $5 million; the Yankees are offering $3 million. I’m rooting for Betances.
This is nothing new in that my allegances are usually with the players: the players, not ownership, put the cans in the seats. However, in this case, reading that the Bombers renewed Betances’ 2016 contract at the major league minimum strikes me as just wrong.
There is obviously something more to the story. Even the cheapest, small market teams usually give tiny raises to young players before they become arbitration eligible.
However, many teams, if the player will not accept the raise the team unilaterally elects to give, whatever that might be, choose to punish the player by renewing him at the minimum for not accepting the unilaterally imposed small raise. I have to think that is why Betances got a $5,000 raise in 2015 which was probably the amount of the rise in the major league minimum and got no raise at all in 2016, when presumably the national cost of living index did not rise and the major league minimum did not go up.
In my mind, it is just so short-sighted. The Yankees are the wealthiest team in baseball, and even if Betances wasn’t willing to accept the raise the Yankees wanted to give him when the Yankees could set whatever raise they wanted, it is just dumb not to give him that raise. Instead, the Yankees elected to punish him to save, what, $50,000 or $100,000? Chump-change in terms of the team’s $225 million plus player payroll, thereby guaranteeing that Betances will never ever give the Yankees one plug nickel when the time comes that Betances is the one with the leverage.
Another element of this story is that Betances is old relative to his major league service time and performance, which will have some impact on his future earning ability. Betances is one in a long line of storied major league pitchers who always had great stuff, but who took a long time to develop command (some of these guys obviously never do).
Betances finally found his command in his age 26 season, and his performance has been other-worldly since then. Still, he sees younger guys making more money because they reached the Show sooner, even if they now aren’t as good. Add to that the fact that the Yankees are so good that despite his tremendous performance over the last three years, he’s notched only 22 saves, because the Yankees always had somebody at least as good with more experience who got the saves opportunities.
In short, Betances feels he deserves to get paid, and the Yankees probably assume that, since they are the rich, rich Yankees, players will always demand top money regardless. Even so, it’s doubtful that taking Betances to arbitration serves the Yankees in the long run.
Maybe the situation with Betances is soured already. However, the Yankees are also sending a message to every other player in the organization that each player ought to stick it to the Yankees or the team will stick it to them.
One thing that has to be remembered is that even as rich as the Yankees are, there are some players who might sign for a little less than absolute top dollar because they want to remain with the franchise that developed them or gave them their first big league opportunity or because they want to play in New York. Some players, like most recently Yoenis Cespedes, really seem to thrive under the brightest lights, or the cultural or life-style options the Big Apple provides. If you’re a player from Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico, Japan, South Korea or a lot of other places, NYC has a lot to offer.
Whether Betances wins or loses the upcoming arbitration hearing, the best revenge will be staying healthy and continuing to strike out more than 11 batters per nine innings pitched. That way, Betances will eventually get the big money from the Yanks or someone else.
Unfortunately, that’s easier said than done. Every pitcher would remain healthy and effective forever if it was solely a matter of hard work and will power. In the meantime, Aroldis Chapman will continue to get the save opportunities, and the Yankees will continue to work Betances hard as a set-up man, since they know they won’t get any team-friendly contract extensions from Betances and his agents any time soon.
Unless, of course, team and player agree to a multi-year extension before the arbitration hearing.