The Yankees Have No Class
Instead of simply savoring their arbitration win over Dellin Betances (he gets the $3 million the Yankees proffered instead of the $5 million he asked for) quietly, Yankees President Randy Levine publicly blasted Betances and his agents today for asking for too much in arbitration. No class.
A player asking for too much in arbitration is a win for the team, since it means it’s that much more likely the arbitrator will pick the team’s number. Meanwhile, Betances responded by saying it will be that much easier for him to leave as a free agent in 2020.
Doesn’t management realize the value of a Dominican American star who was born and raised in New York City? I’m reminded of Joe Dimaggio‘s hold-out in 1938. Dimaggio had an incredible first two major league seasons, was an enormous star in NYC, a city with a huge Italian American population, and Dimag thought he deserved to be paid what he was worth.
The Yankees didn’t give it to him, because in those days they didn’t have to. The reserve clause was in its heyday, and a player had no choice but to hold out until eventually accepting very close to the number the team originally wanted to pay him.
Those times have changed, and treating a box office attraction like Betances like an ingrate jerk just makes no sense. Betances isn’t quite a superstar yet, and he didn’t pitch well in the closer role late last season. However, I think that probably had more to do with a short-sample size slump/fluke or the fact that Betances had been worked hard during the immediately preceding two and two-thirds seasons.
In fact, the Yankees may be betting on the fact that they will succeed in burning out Betances in his set-up role before he can become a free agent. I wouldn’t necessarily count on it. A player of Betances’ size and strikeout rates tends to blow out his knees and back before his pitching arms.
Mark my words — if Betances eventually develops into the closer one has to expect him to become and he’s healthy three years from now, don’t be surprised if Betances signs with the Mets for less than absolute top dollar in order to stick a nail in Yankees management.
Meanwhile, the Yankees are pretty much guaranteed to have one of their stars far less happy than he should be going into the 2017 season. It’s just more evidence that the Bombers are far more willing to be mediocre than they were under King George.