Lately, the tiny island nation of Curacao (current population 150,000) has garnered a lot of attention for all the great baseball players produced there. Before Curacao, the tiny Caribbean island nation (sort of) that produced a surprisingly large number of major league players was the U.S. Virgin Islands.
The first Virgin Islander to play in the major leagues was Valmy Thomas on April 16, 1957. Thomas was born in Puerto Rico, where he later experienced the greatest share of his professional baseball success, because his mother didn’t trust the hospitals in the U.S. Virgin Islands and thought she’d get better care in Puerto Rico. However, mother and baby returned to the Virgin Islands shortly after the delivery. Joe Christopher was the first major league player actually born in the Virgin Islands when he broke in in 1959.
Including Thomas and Julio Navarro, who was also born in Puerto Rico but grew up on St. Croix, at least 16 Virgin Islanders have played in the majors. Here is my list of the best ten:
1. Horace “Hoss” Clarke (1965-1974). The starting 2Bman in the period immediately following the end of the New York Yankees’ multi-decade dynasty, Clarke was in his prime a terrific defensive 2Bman, leading the Junior for six consecutive seasons in assists (1967-1972), four consecutive seasons in putouts (1968-1971) and twice in double plays (1969, 1972). He was also seen as a good lead-off man in his day, but he was definitely an old-school lead-off man who ran well and stole bases but didn’t really get on base enough for the role.
Clarke’s reputation in his own day was affected by the fact that the Yankees were no longer consistent winners, as one of the team’s best players in this era, he took a lot of undeserved heat for it. He also had a reputation for not being tough on hard slides into second base to break up the double play, but as noted above, he did lead the AL twice in turning double plays and never finished lower than 5th (in a 10- or 12-team circuit) in this category in any of the seven seasons between 1967 and 1973. He was also a polite but quiet man who preferred playing musical instruments to talking, something that probably didn’t endear him to sportswriters looking for good quotes and copy.
Like most Virgin Islands players of his era, he played many winters in Puerto Rico where V.I. players were more or less treated like locals, and like several other V.I. players Clarke took a Puerto Rican wife. After his career, Clarke returned to St. Croix, where he taught children to play baseball and also worked for a time as a scout for the Royals.
2. Al McBean (1961-1970). Al McBean is not at all well remembered today, because his nine year Pittsburgh Pirates career was played entirely between the 1960 and 1971 teams that were World Champions. He won 15 games as a starter in 1962 and then was gradually converted to a reliever over the 1963. The Pirates’ top reliever Elroy Face took McBean under his wing and taught McBean how to pitch in relief situations while having McBean over to his house to BBQ.
McBean went 13-3 with 11 saves in 1963, posted a 1.91 ERA with 21 saves (tied for 2nd best in NL behind Hal Woodshick‘s 23 saves) in 1964, and posted a 2.29 ERA with 19 saves (tied for 4th best) in 1965. McBean wasn’t as good after that but remained an effective reliever and starter for the Bucs though 1968.
McBean had a hard sinker that was hard to elevate, and he threw from different arm angles to give hitters diverse looks. He was known for his sense of humor and tried to put on a show for the fans, which sometimes got him called a hot dog. He was also a flashy but stylish for the time (mod) dresser who became famous in Pittsburgh for a white suit, white tie and white shoes ensemble. He sometimes drew comparisons to Muhammad Ali.
McBean also married a Puerto Rican woman named Olga Santos, whom he told the first time he met her that one day he’d marry her. They married about nine months later in Pittsburgh.
Surprisingly, McBean never made an All-Star team, but he played in the one and only Latin American Players’ Game, the last game played at Manhattan’s old Polo Grounds on October 12, 1963, attended by 14,235 fans. It was played for charity with NL and AL squads featuring Roberto Clemente, Orlando Cepeda, Juan Marichal, Luis Aparicio, Minnie Minoso and Tony Oliva among others. The National League team won 5-2, and McBean was involved in the game’s most exciting play: a triple by McBean that drove in Tony Gonzalez but on which McBean was thrown out at home plate on a Minoso to Aparicio to Jose Azcue relay. For what it’s worth, the players on the two teams were disproportionately Cubans, reflecting all the great players coming out of that country before the Revolution.
McBean finished his major league career with a 67-50 record, 63 saves and a 3.13 ERA. He returned St. Thomas after his career, working in housing and recreation for the Virgin Islands government. Needless to say, he thinks most of today’s highly paid stars are soft.
3. Elrod Hendricks (1968-1979). Part of Earl Weaver‘s catcher’s platoons for many years, Hendricks played for much of the Orioles’ greatest period of success between 1966 and 1979. Hendricks didn’t hit for much of an average (.220 lifetime), but he’d take a walk and hit not too infrequent home runs, two things that Earl Weaver loved. In fact, Weaver discovered Hendricks while managing in Puerto Rico after several unsuccessful attempts by Hendricks to establish himself playing in the U.S.
Hendricks was also a fine defensive catcher who throw out 38% of attempted base stealers during his career. He played in five post-seasons, four with the O’s. He played 16 seasons of winter ball in Puerto Rico and was the Orioles’ bullpen coach for a remarkable 28 years.
He was also a great handler of the Orioles’ great pitching staff. He caught Jim Palmer‘s no-hitter on August 13, 1969, and Palmer had great things to say about Hendricks, despite their sometimes contentious disagreements about pitch-calling while Palmer was on the mound.
The most famous play in Hendricks’ career happened in the 1970 World Series. In Game 1 with the score tied 1-1, Reds pinch hitter Ty Cline hit a high chopper off home plate, which Hendricks grabbed with his bare hand. Berno Carbo came charging in from third trying to score. Hendricks lunged towards Carbo trying to apply the tag as umpire Ken Burkhart moved forward to call the batted ball fair. Burkhart and Hendricks collided, spinning Burkhart to the ground as Hendricks tagged Carbo with his empty mitt. Burkhart called Carbo out, and Carbo and Reds manager Sparky Anderson argued vociferously. This was before instant replay replay reversal, but the instant replays on TV showed clearly, both that Hendricks had tagged Carbo with the wrong hand and that Carbo had completely missed home plate. Carbo did not touch home until he did so unaware as he argued with Burkhart. Here is the replay from youtube.
4. Jose “Shady” Morales (1973-1984). Morales and Manny Mota were generally recognized as baseball’s best pinch hitters during the 1970’s. Morales’ 25 pinch hits in 1976 broke Dave Philley‘s 1961 record (tied by Vic Davalillo in 1970) and lasted until John Vander Wal stoked 28 in 1995.
Jose Morales’ had started his professional career as a catcher because of his strong arm, but developed a reputation as a defensive liability there. Becoming a top pinch hitter kept on major league rosters, and he later had success as part of a DH platoon for the Minnesota Twins.
Morales played professionally for more than twenty seasons, including two decades of Winter ball in Puerto Rico. When he retired his 123 career major league pinch hits was third best all-time, and he still ranks 8th best all-time. He then worked as a hitting coach and instructor and now lives in the Orlando area.
5. Jerry Browne (1986-1995). Known as the “Guv’nor,” Browne had his best season as the starting 2Bman for the 1989 Indians, when he slashed .299/.370/.390. Despite being a fast base runner who got on base, Browne was inconsistent and wasn’t good at turning the double play. Ultimately, he developed into a utility man who played 2B, 3B and all three outfield positions. He’s done some couching for major league organizations and now lives in Texas.
6. Joe Christopher (1959-1966). Joe Christopher had one great major league season when he was one of the few bright spots on a dreadful 1964 Mets team. He slashed .300/.360/.466 and recorded 10 assists as the team’s primary right-fielder. As a pinch-runner for the Pirates, “Hurryin’ Joe” scored two runs in the 1960 World Series.
He was the fifth player drafted by the expansion 1962 Mets. His most vivid memory of the 1962 season was teaching center fielder Richie Ashburn how to say “Yo la Tengo” (“I got it!”) so that he wouldn’t collide with Venezuelan shortstop Elio Chacon, only to have Ashburn get run over by the much larger left fielder Frank Thomas.
Christopher credited his hitting success in 1964 in part to a pamphlet written by Paul Waner, which Christopher sent away for for 50 cents based on an add in the Sporting News, and a meeting he had with Waner in 1961. Christopher also played in Puerto Rico for many winters and married a Puerto Rican woman, although the marriage lasted only about six years. After baseball, he went into advertising.
7. Midre Cummings (1993-2005). Cummings moved to Florida for his final year of high school and became a first round draft pick for the Twins (29th overall in 1990). He developed a reputation in baseball, perhaps unjustly, as a player with a lot of talent but who had a bad head in that he was too lackadaisical in his training and work habits. He was never able to establish himself as an everyday player at the major league level, but he eventually established himself as an effective pinch hitter, leading his league several times in pinch hits.
The highlight of Cummings’ major league career, perhaps, was the 2001 post-season, where like Joe Christopher before him, he was used primarily as a pinch runner and scored three runs, two of them in the World Series, including the tying run in the bottom of the ninth inning in Game 7. Cummings now lives in Tampa and coaches children.
8. Jharel Cotton (2016-2017). Cotton came to the U.S. at the age of 16. He went 9-10 with a 5.58 ERA as a rookie starting pitcher for the A’s in 2017. He’s got a live arm, but he will be 26 in 2018, so we’ll see where his career goes. On August 9, 2016, Cotton fell one batter short of pitching a perfect game in the AAA Pacific Coast League, allowing a triple to the 27th batter with two outs in the ninth.
9. Calvin Pickering (1998-2005). Pickering also moved to Florida for his final year of high school. Although a 35th round draft pick, he showed both a tremendous ability to hit and to hit for power as soon as he started his professional career. Alas, weight issues (he reported to Spring Training at least one year weighing 300 lbs and never played at much less than 260) and the injuries that came with them prevented him from becoming a major league star.
Pickering hit 35 home runs at AAA Omaha in only 379 plate appearances during his age 27 season and played for half a season in South Korea’s KBO two years later.
10. Valmy Thomas (1957-1961). My next post will be devoted to Valmy Thomas, who had a very interesting professional career.